원문 보기
He was the lonely genius Wall Street feared. So, you made a ton of money. Made a ton of money. Much more than I ever imagined, you know, I'd ever have. From Silicon Investor forums to a garage hedge fund, Michael Bur hunted value in forgotten corners, crushed the dot wreckage, then forged weapons no bank had imagined to bet against American housing itself.
From making hundreds of millions in 2008 to seeding the GameStop saga with early activist letters to becoming a victim of a rigged system, closing his fund and quitting forever. Michael Bur is the tragic contrarian of finance. Everybody was just a bunch of criminals. I think the story is much more interesting than that.
I think it's a story of mass delusion. In the early 1970s, San Jose, California, stands as a bustling hub in the heart of what will become Silicon Valley. Semiconductors and tech startups begin to sprout amid orchards, signaling a shift from agriculture to innovation while the nation grapples with the winding down of the Vietnam War and rising inflation that pinches middle class families.
Michael Bur enters the world in 1971 and grows up in an intellectual household. But tragedy strikes early when at age 2, Bur loses his left eye to a rare cancer called retinol blasto, replaced by a prosthetic that becomes a constant reminder of vulnerability. Bullied relentlessly by classmates who mock his glass eye and beg him to remove it.
He retreats into solitude, finding solace in books and observation rather than play. Michael was always the quiet observer. Even as a teenager, he dissected everything. Conversations, games, even stock tables, his dad showed him with a precision that set him apart. Social cues often escaped him, leading to isolation.
But that same detachment honed his analytical edge, making him see patterns others missed. Bur excels in high school and heads to UCLA for economics and premed, followed by medical school at Vanderbilt. Bur is on his way to become a doctor, but fate has a different plan for him. In the late 1990s, Michael Bur dives into neurology residency at Stamford University Hospital after earning his MD from Vanderbilt.
He throws himself into long hours, mastering the intricacies of the brain. On track to become a full-fledged doctor, but even as he excels in medicine, a pull towards something else begins to grow. Off duty, Bur turns to investing as a side passion, sparked by childhood glimpses of stock tables from his father and deepened by the value investing principles of Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett.
The first rule in investment is don't lose. And the second rule on investment is don't forget the first rule. And that's all the rules there are. I mean that uh if you buy things for far below what they're worth and you buy a group of them, you basically don't lose money. Warren Buffett, the legendary oracle of Omaha, rises from modest beginnings to build Berkshire Hathaway into a powerhouse by buying undervalued companies and holding them long-term.
Bur admires Buffett's contrarian style, going against the crowd to spot hidden gems, and sees investing as a marathon sport he can master, much like Buffett, by focusing on fundamentals over hype. And soon, Bur finds an unexpected avenue for his passion. Back in the mid 1990s, online finance forums like Silicon Investor um were naented uh digital forums with bulletin boards where finance enthusiasts debated stocks.
These communities were small and merit-based. Anyone with solid analysis could shine regardless of credentials. Outsiders like doctors or hobbyists stood out because the forums rewarded deep research over insider connections, leveling the playing field in ways traditional finance never did. Under pseudonyms, Bur posts detailed stock picks on sites like Silicon Investor, impressing users with his precise breakdowns of company values.
His contrarian calls, often spotting overlooked opportunities, build a following as his predictions pay off. Soon, he's seen as an elite picker in these niche circles, all while keeping his medical life secret. The thrill of markets pulls stronger than hospital shifts, especially with profits mounting from his value bets.
Before long, Bur makes a decision that feels all but inevitable. By the late 1990s, Michael Burray is deep into his neurology residency at Stamford Hospital, a prestigious program that promises a stable, high-ning career as a doctor. At 29, he's married with a young son, earning a resident salary of around $50,000 while managing family finances after his father's death.
Conventionally, he's on a golden path. Medicine offers security, respect, and intellectual challenge. Far from the risks of other fields. But Bur's online investing success changes everything. His stock picks yield strong returns, outpacing his medical income and fueling a passion that medicine can't match.
Dissatisfied with the social demands of patient care, exacerbated by his self-dagnosed asperers, he sees finance as a realm where his analytical strengths shine without interpersonal strain. I realized medicine wasn't for me. Investing let me focus purely on ideas and numbers. Quitting felt like breaking free to pursue what truly fit my mind.
Bur wants to raise money to start his own investment fund, but it feels impossible to launch a fund. He will need more than just his own money. He will need a backer for Bur. He knows just where to look. Joel Greenblat is as a master of value investing, founding Gotham Capital in 1985 with backing from junk bond pioneer Michael Milin.
A Wharton graduate, he builds a concentrated portfolio around undervalued assets and special situations. His sharp eye turns modest capital into legend. Greenblat's philosophy demands high returns on capital paired with bargain prices, often in spin-offs, mergers, and restructurings ignored by the crowd.
From 1985 to 1994, Gotham delivers staggering 50% annualized returns before fees, 34% net. In the late 1990s.com frenzy, Greenblat monitors online forums, spotting a relentless poster dissecting value plays with surgical depth. Michael Bur, the anonymous doctor turned analyst. Bur's picks echo Greenblat's own contrarian rigor untainted by Wall Street polish.
He sees raw talent ready to explode. Launching a fund required pedigree like Ivy degrees or Goldman Sachs experience or a blazing TR record. By summer 2000, Bur quits medicine cold June 30th, armed with barely a million in personal seed. Inheritance from his father's botched cancer death, plus family scraps, mom's $20,000, brothers $10,000 each, no Wall Street rolodex, no track record beyond forum ghosts.
He needs believers who bet on brains over badges. Greenblat, already quietly profiting from Bur's Silicon Investor posts, acts decisively. He contacts Bur. In 2000, Gotham seeds Scion with $1 million, buying a 25% stake in the fledgling fund. Soon after, White Mountain's insurance group, led by Jack Burn in Buffett's Circle, follows Gotham's lead and acquires an equity portion after tracking the same online insights.
Now, with the money secured, he just needs a big idea. And soon, a monumental event is on the horizon. In the late 1990s, America rides a wave of tech excitement as the internet sparks dreams of endless growth with companies like Amazon and Cisco soaring on hype alone. The NASDAQ climbs over 5,000 by March 2000, fueled by easy money and investor frenzy.
People were feeling it, getting paid, loving these markets, high-fiving it, confident across the board. Michael Bur has left medicine behind. Built a name on online forums and launched Scion Capital in 2000 with seed cash from his family Joel Greenblat and White Mountains. Now with a fund running, he hunts for ways to prove its worth in a wild market.
Early wins are key to draw more investors and build trust. Murray goes against the crowd right away, shorting hot tech stocks like those in the NASDAQ frenzy while buying cheap, forgotten firms in old sectors like manufacturing and retail. He spots value in places others ignore, such as small companies trading below their real worth, holding them long as the market crashes.
Bur's plan was classic value investing. And sometimes you have to be a contrarian by going against what everyone else chases because the market tend to overreact and create bargains. It worked in a dark bubble where growth dreams blinded people to real risks. These bets pay off big. Scion jumps 55% in 2001 while the S&P drops 12% then adds 16% in 2002 against a 22% market fall.
His shorts on overpriced.com names crush it as the bubble pops, turning losses for most into gains for him. After the dotcom bubble bursts in 2000, America climbs back with steady growth fueled by low interest rates from the Federal Reserve, sparking a housing boom and consumer spending that lifts the economy.
The stock market rebounds strong. The S&P 500 rises over 60% from 2003 to 2006 as jobs return and tech survivors like Google drive innovation. Scion Capital thrives in the aftermath with Bur's value bets paying off big. 55% return in 2001 as markets tank 16% in 2002's route, then 50% in 2003's rebound.
Assets swell from a few million to 600 million by 2004, drawing quiet investors who see his edge. He keeps hunting cheap stocks, shorting hype, building a track record that crushes the S and P year year after year. By mid 2005, the fund is up 242% since start, a feat few could match in the investment world.
Bur around then was this intense solitary figure pouring over data like a detective in a quiet room. His strategy boiled down to pure value, buying what others ignored, betting against crowds, and it demanded a personality that thrived on being right when everyone else was wrong. He didn't chase fame, he chased truth in numbers.
Bur's fund has performed well, but a bigger opportunity is yet to come, and it will propel Bur into unimaginable height. In the mid 2000s, America plunges into a housing frenzy as the Federal Reserve slashes interest rates to historic lows. After the dotcom bust and 9/11 shocks, flooding the economy with cheap credit that ignites borrowing and building, lenders loosen rules dramatically, pushing subprime loans, risky mortgages for borrowers with poor credit, often with no down payment, no income checks, or teaser rates that reset higher later.
Home prices doubled in many areas from 2000 to 2006, driven by speculation where flippers bought to resell fast for profit, and government policies pushed home ownership to unprecedented highs near 70%. Rampant cash out refinancing had already made the home a magical ATM for most Americans. Profits explode.
Top investment banks like Lehman Brothers leverage up to 30 to 40 times their capital, turning small asset gains into massive returns while the boom lasts. Subprime lending jumps from under 10% of mortgages in 2001 to over 20% by 2006 with private securitization dominating as Wall Street packages risky loans into a AAA rated bonds.
That period was a pure madness, a classic speculative bubble where everybody believed that a housing prices could only go up, ignoring history and basics and lenders would give money to anyone and really agencies stamped uh drunk as gold. It was insane how detached from reality the whole system was.
The surreal growth of the housing market catches the attention of a skeptical young man and soon he will uncover a massive opportunity of a lifetime. By mid 2005, Michael Bur's Scion Capital stands as a powerhouse. Assets ballooned to $600 million. His fund's cumulative 242% gain since 2000 outpaces the S&P by miles.
All from spotting value where crowds see trash and shorting hype before it bursts. This outsers's edge honed through solitary digs into data cements him as a quiet force in finance. It is the year of 2004. As Bur scans for market edges as a value hunter, he pulls prospectuses on mortgage back securities, curious about the bonds fueling the boom.
I called up the prospectuses and I read the prospectuses and I looked at these polls. By early 2005, buried in thousands of pages of pool data, the anomalies jump out and grip him. He uncovers special home loans called teaser rate adjustable mortgages. These are often 2/28 loans that start with a very low interest rate around 7 to 8% for the first 2 years to lure people in, but then jump sharply to a much higher rate like 12 to 13% or more after that period ends.
In other words, borrowers get a cheap deal at first, but then face payments they often can't handle. Essentially, crappier mortgages being put into these pools, and it didn't seem investors seem to care, and it didn't seem the ratings agencies seem to care. These risky loans given mostly to people with weak credit called subprime borrowers are bundled together into big investment packages called bonds that are strangely rated as safe by agencies even though the loans inside are dangerous.
He notices for the first time that there are pools there they're mortgage bonds supported by pools of loans and most of the loans are what are called negative amvertising interestonly loans which means that you the homeowner and buyer you borrow the money and you not only don't have to re repay your principal you have to you don't have to repay the interest and if you just don't pay anything they just they just add to your loan.
Simply put, Bur sees early warning signs. Many borrowers in the newest 2005 loan groups are already falling behind on payments even before the rates go up, which points to widespread cheating, like liar loans, where people fake their income to qualify, or loans where monthly payments are so low they don't even cover the interest.
So, the total debt actually grows over time instead of shrinking. and stated income, a stated income option available to borrowers inspired a new vernacular, the liar loan. I was pouring over those mortgage perspectuses night after night, and it hit me. These teaser rates were traps set to explode in 2 years, luring folks who never should have qualified.
The early delinquencies and fresh pools told the real story. Fraud everywhere, borrowers underwater from day one, and no one pricing in the reset wave. I knew then the whole housing edifice was built on sand. defaults would avalanche by 2007 and I had to find a way to bet against it. Spotting the fracture is one thing.
Turning insight into profit is a totally different game. The problem is there is no way to do a massive short on subprime bonds yet. Michael Bur's thesis is clear. The housing market is a ticking bomb, stuffed with bad loans set to explode in 2007 when rates reset and borrowers default on mass. To profit from the crash, he needs a way to bet against it.
But no tool exists to short mortgage bonds directly. In a stroke of genius, he dreams up using credit default swaps like insurance policies on those bonds, paying small premiums now for huge payouts if they fail. To pull it off, Bur must convince big banks to create these custom swaps on subprime mortgage bundles.
He needs ironclad contracts to trade them later without hassle. For months, Bur flies across the country to visit Wall Street giants like Goldman Sachs and Deutsche Bank, pitching his wild idea to short the hottest market around. Wall Street laughs at the quirky California outsider demanding custom swaps on risky subprime bonds.
Murray persists with data that stuns them. Deutsche bites first May 19th, 2005. 60 million BBB. Goldman and others follow. Premiums haggled low. Position swells to $1 billion by end 2005. $8 billion notional by 2006. Bur looked absolutely a nuts back then, betting billions against America's dream asset, and no one has done that before.
Bur stands rock solid on his math, convinced the resets will trigger apocalypse. But the problem is his investors don't share same conviction. Michael Bur locks in his massive wager. Billions in credit default swaps on subprime mortgage bonds, a fortress built to capture the coming collapse. These swaps work like fire insurance on houses you don't own.
Bur pays uh ongoing premiums about 2% or less of the covered amount every year to banks like Goldman Sachs or Deutsch Bank. In other words, it's money out the door every quarter to keep the policy active. Simply put, no fire means premiums vanish forever, dragging fund returns down while waiting. But if defaults hit and bonds burn, the payout explodes up to 100 times the premiums or more, delivering windfall as the insured bonds crater.
Bur's investors, mostly wealthy individuals, family offices, and institutions, start calm but turn hostile as housing prices climb and premiums eat 18 to 20% returns in 2006. They flood him with angry calls and letters, demanding he ditch the crazy bet that's bleeding cash while everyone else profits from the boom.
Some threaten lawsuits. Redemptions pour in as fear spreads. Even Greenblat, his first big backer, whose Gotham had grown to $100 million in Scion, faces his own client withdrawals and flies west with partner John Petri to confront Bur, pressuring him to unwind. Bur holds firm, side pocketing the swaps, locking that money so investors can't pull it, forcing them to ride the storm.
Bur looked like a madman to his own backers, pouring millions into premiums on a sure thing market no one thought could fail. It was classic contrarian pain. Genius isolated as the crowd feasts. Markets keep rising into 2007. Premiums drain deeper. Redemptions mount. Personal attacks sting. If Bur's wrong, no defaults come.
Premiums exhaust capital. He will lose everything. By late 2006, America basks in a false golden age. Housing prices peak after years of wild growth with homes flipping for quick profits and families tapping equity like endless ATMs. The only thing as you mentioned really the only uh similarity with 2007 the most noticeable is just the chart is hitting the all-time highs.
The fundamentals are completely different. The valuations are completely different. When you look at small and midcap and how they're behaving, that's completely different. Stocks hit records with the Dow over 12,000. Jobs plentiful in construction and finance. The American dream thrives. Home ownership hits 69%.
Middle class wealth feels real. We saw American home prices, which had largely moved in line with household income over the decades, suddenly accelerate up and away from the household income trend line. But inequality widens as wages flatline. For many, debt piles high. But by mid 2007, foreclosures spiked 93% year-over-year.
Hedge funds wobble on bad mortgage bets. The crisis, in my view, would start in 2007, by which time teaser rate periods on the vast majority of these new types of mortgages would expire or reset for a population of homeowners trapped in mortgages they can no longer afford. The stage sets for shatter.
This is the exact moment Bur has been waiting for. I have X on an 86. In summer 2007, subprime defaults surge. Early resets on 2005 loans hit borrowers hard. Delinquencies jump to 13% by July. His credit default swaps twitch as bond values dip. First payouts trickle in from counterparties like Deutsche Bank.
July, signaling the poison spreads. But the real payout for Michael Bur will come later. In 2008, the crisis hit hard. Bear Sterns rescued in March. India failed in summer. Fanny Freddy seized in September. Lehman bankrupt on the 15th. AIG bailed out huge on the 16th. Markets tanked 18% in a week. Worst panic since 1931.
While hedge funds bleed, averaging 19% losses in 2008. Giants like Citadel down 55%. Bur's scion soarses. His $1 billion in credit default swaps on subprime BBB trenches pay off huge as defaults cascade, netting $720 million for the fund after $85 million in premiums. Scion posts 80% gains in 2007 amid early cracks, then 166% in 2008's Inferno.
total 489% from 2000 to 2008 versus SNP's 3%. Bur pockets $100 million personally. His contrarian fortress turning crisis into conquest. Bur looked insane betting against housing when everyone was feasting. But to him, the collapse was inevitable math. When it hit, his swaps exploded. Hundreds of millions in profit.
The Contrarian won big. As the dust settles upon the 2008 inferno that consumes trillions, Michael Bur stands not as a survivor, but a victor. Scion Capital reaps over 700 million in gains for investors with over $100 million for himself. But for Bur, he realizes that it's a hollow victory. The very apocalypse that crowns him with wealth devastates countless families through foreclosures and despair.
But joy eludes the man who saw it coming all along. Exhausted by the investor revolt that preceded victory, including IRS audits and backlash over profiting from crisis, Bur wins down Scion Capital in late 2008. He returns capital to remaining backers. I closed Scion because managing external capital under that pressure with regulators circling just wasn't worth it anymore.
I needed peace to invest my way on my terms. The big short book in 2010 and film in 2015 catapult Bur to celebrity status, thrusting his private life into spotlight he never sought. In 2013, he relaunched under Scan Asset Management, a new entity registered with the SEC. This wasn't a full-blown hedge fund comeback.
It was smaller, more selective, managing around $100 to $200 million at peaks. He invests personally farmland, water rights, gold while staying lowprofile, raising family in California. I believe that agriculture land, productive agricultural land with water on site is will be very valuable in the future and I've put a good amount of money into that.
So, I've I'm I'm investing in alternative investments as well as stocks. Twitter becomes his sporadic outlet. Cryptic posts on markets often deleted to dodge bots and noise until full account wipes in cycles of frustration. Bur remains a digital ghost. Active online in bursts, sharing warnings on bubbles or value ideas via Twitter before deletions.
But soon, a monumental event erupts in the online trading forums he once haunted. And once again, Michael Bur will be propelled to the public eye. In the 20110s, online trading forums explode as cheap apps like Robin Hood let everyday people buy stocks with no fees, turning investing into a game for millions.
There's a new behavior that's possible with Robin Hood that hasn't really been possible before. Reddit's Wall Street Bets subreddit starts in 2012 as a small spot for risky bets and jokes, growing huge by 2020 with pandemic lockdowns and stimulus checks, giving people extra cash and time. These communities share memes, big wins, and bold calls building a new army of retail traders who challenge Wall Street pros at GameStop.
A struggling video game store chain catches attention in 2019 as its stock falls low while sitting on cash and facing heavy short bets from hedge funds expecting bankruptcy. Michael Bur jumps in first during 2018 to 2019, building a 3 to 5% stake in GameStop at low prices around $3 to $4 per share. He writes open letters to the board in 2019 urging massive buybacks with the company's cash to shrink shares and boost value.
His activist push highlights the deep discount and short squeeze potential. Bur's moves put GameStop on radar for value investors online. You might remember the chaos in the stock market over the course of several days this past January when amateur traders following a Reddit subgroup called Wall Street Bets created chaos for the stock market using a mobile trading app to buy up shares in GameStop, the video game retail chain that was valued at less than $20 a share in early January and then skyrocketed to nearly $500 a share in just a matter of days.
The explosion hits in January 2021 as Wall Street Bets users led by Roaring Kitty Keith Gil pile in to squeeze shorts. Amber Mckenry, members of the committee, I am happy to discuss with the committee my purchases of GameStop shares and my discussions of their fair value on social media. It is true that my investment in that company multiplied in value many times.
Stock rockets from $20 to $483 peak, up over 2,000%. Hedge funds like Melvin Capital lose billions, 53% down in January, needing $2.75 billion bailout, while others close positions in pain. Retail traders make paper millions. Brokers halt buys amid chaos. Some trading platforms, including Robin Hood and Interactive Brokers, have had to suspend certain trades in some of these names, including GameStop.
For the most part, you can no longer buy it, but you can sell it. Bur plays no direct role in the squeeze. He sold late 2020 at around 15 to 20 average, profiting 100 to $270 million on his early bet, but his letters and stake helped spark awareness. Bur's fame skyrockets again from big short echoes, turning him into a meme hero for spotting value early.
But the spotlight weighs heavy on his private nature, and it will eventually become his downfall. In the early 2020s, America rides an AI wave as tech giants like Nvidia surge on chips powering everything from chat bots to self-driving cars. With the NASDAQ up 50% in 2023 alone, amid low rates and post-pandemic innovation hype, Tesla's stock triples from 2020 lows to over $400 by 2025, driven by electric vehicle dreams and robo taxi promises, boosting Elon Musk's wealth to $300 billion and cementing him as a cultural icon, visionary entrepreneur, Twitter owner, space pioneer.
Together we rise as NASA SpaceX heads up. Michael Bur blasts the AI frenzy as a classic bubble, comparing it to mania with overvalued stocks like Nvidia propped by hype over real earnings. He shorts AI darlings, warning of 1920s level speculation and accounting tricks inflating profits. Furry mocks Tesla's ridiculous overvaluation, calling Musk's fans a cult shifting from EVs to autonomy to robots as competition bites.
His views stem from value roots, spotting disconnects between prices and fundamentals in a market chasing narratives. In 2021, he shorts Tesla, tweets bearish calls, feuds with Musk, who dubs him a broken clock, then deletes his account amid backlash. He resurfaces sporadically, predicting bubbles in crypto, stocks, and housing.
Often right long-term, but wrong on timing. Like his 2021 Tesla shortest shares soared 50% after. Last December, uh, he had tweeted at Elon Musk that he was shorting Tesla, he since deleted his Twitter, which is pretty unfortunate considering Tesla has just fallen so far this year, lost about a quarter of its value in the first quarter.
Previous concerns he's had about Tesla has a lot to do with valuation, so that might be driving it. In 2023, he warns of bankr runs pre-SVB collapse. Nails it partially. By 2025, he shorts Nvidia and Palanteer, posts cryptic charts on AI overvaluation, calls Tesla a delilution machine. Many bets lag as markets rally, drawing mockery for being early or off.
Tweets vanish quickly, accounts deleted multiple times to dodge noise. My number one concern is there's been a complete utter total abdication of personal responsibility throughout our entire society. I don't think that anyone anywhere is taking blame themselves for what they did to contribute to the crisis.
In 2025, America rides an AI boom that props up growth. Tech capex like data centers adds over 1% to GDP in early quarters with hyperscalers spending $400 billion on infrastructure amid NASDAQ surges. But for Bur, it is bad news. Fed up with bots, critics, and endless debates, Bur wipes his Twitter in late 2025, going silent online.
This retreat hints at deeper weariness. Soon, facing market rifts and personal toll, he makes a final pivot. closing Scion Asset Management for good. So yeah, what this would suggest if you're you're going to read it one way is, you know, perhaps Bur is, you know, you know, shuttering to outside investors or perhaps shuttering the whole hedge fund.
He's obviously did that before. He did that in 2008 with the predecessor firm before coming back. Michael Bur dregisters Scion Asset Management in November 2025, liquidating external funds and returning capital after managing $155 million. He cites prolonged disconnect. his value views out of sync with raging markets, making outside money unwise amid bearish bets like AI shorts.
So, I think that Bur closed the fund possibly from exhaustion, years of contrarian shorts, lagging rallies, client pressure just like the 2008 revolt. The divergence really wore him down. You know, maybe he was right when Bur said the entire world was a fraud in a sense that he was really a tragic figure.
He was right when crowds were wrong, rich when empires burned. But the game, often rigged by hype and herd, often goes on longer than he anticipates.
Comments 0