Michael Saylor Is Talking Nonsense 💩 Peter Schiff on Bitcoin vs Gold

요약 보기

결론: 피터 쉬프는 비트코인이 금을 대체할 수 없으며 화폐가 될 수 없다고 주장한다. 비트코인과 금 비교 - 비트코인은 금의 물리적 특성(보석 제작, 전기 전도 등)이 없어 화폐 대체가 불가능하다고 주장 - 블록체인은 금을 더 효율적으로 쓰게 하는 개선 수단일 뿐, 화폐 기준은 금이어야 한다고 주장 마이클 세일러 반박 - 세일러가 금의 단점으로 운송 어려움을 든 것에 대해, 대부분 사람은 금을 기차로 옮길 만큼 보유하지 않는다고 반박 - 운송 문제는 과거 마차 시대에도 금이 화폐로 기능했던 점을 들어 근거가 약하다고 주장 - 세일러의 주장 전반을 '허튼소리'로 규정 발언의 성격 - 세일러가 비트코인 보유자로서 매수를 유도하려 한다고 비판 - 이 영상 중반 이후는 'Brian Rose'의 DeFi 아카데미 유료 강의 광고(수강생 후기, 가입 유도)로 구성됨 언급 종목·자산 방향 - 비트코인: 가격 방향 예측 발언 없음(화폐 기능 부정 및 금 대체 불가 주장만 있음) - 금: 화폐 기준으로서 유지되어야 한다는 장기 견해만 있음 리스크 - 영상 자체의 투자 조언 없음, 광고성 강의 판매 목적 포함 출연자 전망 - 쉬프: 비트코인 장기 가치 부정적, 금 중시 견해(단기 가격 전망 없음)

다듬은 글

※ 자동 자막 원문(다듬기 전)

01. But you're essentially saying that you like blockchain because it's essentially a public ledger. And it allows everyone to see everything that's happening, and you can check it out. Just like I guess you might use a checkbook at an old school bank where you had gold on deposit. So you're not against blockchain per se, as long as there's something real behind it as an asset , which in this case would be gold.

02. Yes, I mean, it would be an improvement that would make gold more convenient to use, because the main argument for the digital era is to simply use blockchain to make gold more efficient. But ultimately, the monetary standard must remain unchanged . You can't just rethink gold and say, "Oh, forget about gold." We will say that Bitcoin is gold.” Bitcoin is not gold .

03. It does not have any of the physical properties that gold has. Therefore, you cannot use Bitcoin to make jewelry. You cannot use Bitcoin to conduct electricity . So you can't replace, ahem, gold with Bitcoin. And, and, and so, you know, it can't be money. Not quite. I mean... Well, Tiffany says you can.

04. But, uh, yes, I understand your point. Well, uh, your, uh, your good friend, uh, Michael Saylor, you know, his main argument against gold is that, you know, to transport it, you have to put it on a freight train and, you know, transport it across the country. He will be here in a few weeks. I know we're still waiting for the debate between you two .

05. But that's its main , you know, disadvantage against gold is that it can't be transported. Well, first of all, most people will never own enough gold to require a freight train to transport it. Good. I mean, most people wouldn't be able to afford enough gold to fill a shoebox. And so you can easily transport all your gold.

06. You don't need a freight train. I mean, maybe Michael Saylor is so rich that he needs a whole freight train to transport his gold. Does he have billions of dollars in gold? You probably know this. You know. I don't know. Good. This is a truck full of... I've never... I've never held a billion dollars' worth of gold in my hands , but a million dollars' worth of gold is very light.

07. I mean, again , you know, you can put it in a briefcase. Uh, and, and, and walking around him. I mean, maybe you know, so, um, I think that's not a good reason to be against gold. And of course, you know, that did n't stop gold from functioning as money, you know, 100 years ago, or 200 years ago, or 300 years ago.

08. It worked great. Even though, you know, if you had that much of it, uh , you know, it was hard to move. And you know, we did n't even have freight trains. You know, gold was money, you know, before we had engines . I mean, it could have been transported in a horse-drawn carriage. And if so, what if you couldn't say, "Hey, gold is too heavy for a horse." I mean, of course, that argument might have had more validity then than it does now.

09. This is just a bunch of nonsense. And almost everything that comes out of Saylor's mouth when it comes to Bitcoin or gold is a bunch of nonsense. That's why this guy doesn't want to argue with me. Because I'm exposing, you know, all the nonsense he's talking about Bitcoin and gold. Listen, he's making his point.

10. He has a bunch of Bitcoins and you need to convince other people to buy them. And so, you know, he has to say whatever crazy things he can think of to convince people to overpay for Bitcoin and not buy gold. Hey, do you want to make a profit from cryptocurrency? Then join my DeFi Academy. Crypto-DeFi Academy will help you create wealth for generations.

11. But don't take my word for it. Listen to my students. When I first started getting into cryptocurrency, I remember thinking to myself: I need to learn more. Brian Rose, studying cryptocurrency, studying DeFi, had to do this. I'm so grateful I took the plunge and did it. I had to overcome some limiting beliefs that I could do this, that I could afford this, that I could be in this.

12. It challenges the things that are deeply ingrained in us. Joining DeFi Academy was one of the best decisions I made on my blockchain journey. This course changed my life, changed the rules of the game, a huge discovery, because I knew practically nothing, and the speed of learning over more than 4 weeks was simply fantastic.

13. The information you provided in this session was invaluable. I feel much more confident about my next steps. You took complex concepts and made them easier to understand. What's different from many others is that it doesn't just tell you what to do. He actually makes you do it. This is for people who are serious about becoming traders.

14. This is how it should be done. From this learning experience, I realized again that the most important thing is not what you learn, but who you learn from. The energy was crazy. I have never felt such incredible energy in my life named Brian Rose. You are a legend, my friend. This is the only place on the market where you can get all the information and learn everything you need to know.

15. Everything is so clear and so well done, and I am just eternally grateful for this program. She made me more confident about cryptocurrency than before. I didn't expect how much I would admire her. This course was a great learning experience for me, not only in the crypto space, but also in overall life balance.

16. What I learned was how to take control of my life in a way that I really...really hadn't before. Yes, it's impossible to put a price on that, really. I would recommend it to anyone. First class. Perfection doesn't come cheap. You know, so if you want perfection, you have to pay for it , but it's worth it.

17. Pull the trigger. That's what this course is about. You won't regret it. Really. This is great. Thank you, Brian and team. So what are you waiting for? Cryptocurrency is happening now. Follow the link below, submit your application, and let me be your mentor in creating wealth for generations and building the decentralized financial infrastructure of the future.