저자: PeterSchiff · 외국인
요약 보기
결론: 2017년 시점 영상에서 Peter Schiff은 비트코인을 디지털 금이 아닌 투기자산으로 보며 금이 더 나은 베팅이라고 주장한다. [비트코인 평가] - 비트코인은 디지털 금이 아니라 '디지털 바보 금'이며, 오늘의 비트코인은 내일의 비니 베이비일 수 있다고 주장. - 실사용처가 거의 없고 상인들도 달러로 가격을 매기며 BitPay를 통해 결제받는다고 지적. - 중국 등에서 자본통제 우회 수단으로 쓰인다는 점을 언급. - 공급 한도가 없어 수백 개의 다른 디지털 화폐가 생길 수 있다고 주장. [금 평가] - 금은 화폐가 되기 전부터 고유한 물리적 특성과 희소성으로 가치를 인정받았다는 점을 강조. - 비트코인은 5~10년 전만 해도 존재하지 않았고 내재가치가 없다고 주장. [반론 측] - 상대측(BK)은 비트코인이 단순 금이 아닌 핀테크 플랫폼이며 연준, 영란은행, JP모건, 골드만삭스 등이 관련 프로젝트를 진행 중이라고 주장. - 비트코인 시총이 1%만 점유해도 현재 $1,200에서 $4,500, 5%면 $22,000 수준이라는 시나리오 제시. [청중 투표] - 패널 투표 결과는 2대1로 Peter Schiff(금) 측이 우세. - 금 측 Tim은 금을 포트폴리오에 과도하게 담지 말라는 조언, 비트코인 측 Karen은 금융·투기 요소를 강조. [단기 전망] - Schiff는 단기적으로 금이 비트코인보다 성과가 좋을 것이라고 전망. [리스크·조건] - 비트코인은 일일 변동성이 극심해 교환수단으로 부적합하다는 지적. - 금 측은 금을 '베팅으로 농장을 걸지 말라'며 과도한 보유를 경계.
다듬은 글
what is a better bet going forward gold or Bitcoin BK you first yeah well for me obviously it's big good and I'll tell you why because bitcoin is not just digital gold I think that's what a lot of people get wrong right here it's a technology platform that FinTech is being built on top of it is a once in a generation investment opportunity similar to the internet growing just as fast if not faster it's the Internet of money and I'm not the only one on this everybody's involved in Federal Reserve just released a paper on it and has a working group Bank of England is involved in it 14 of the top 30 banks have active project going on JPMorgan Goldman Sachs cme NYC New York Stock Exchange are all involved in projects as we speak building on top of this technology so let's just say I you know let's just say let's try to put a value on Bitcoin and let's say all those things don't happen right even though there's so many so much people working on it they're building on top of the platform giving it useful let's say it is digital gold and for some reason it just happens to get one percent of the market share that goal get bitcoins be forty five hundred dollars trading at twelve hundred dollars right now if it got five percent of the market share it would be a twenty-two thousand dollars that to me is a winning investment leadership Europe well you know it's not digital gold I agree it's digital fools bold you know today's bitcoins could be tomorrow's beanie babies the whole principle behind bitcoin bitcoin was to replicate the properties that that made gold uniquely suited to be money and act as an alternative to to fiat currencies but it's not really a viable as money i mean it is a potential medium of exchange but it's not a store value meanwhile nobody really uses it as a medium of exchange it's just a speculative asset people own it because they think it's going to be more valuable in the future but it has no intrinsic value in and of itself if t thousand merchants worldwide accept Bitcoin its concluding expedia no no no thousands no hundred thousand twelve actions a day let no merchants accept Bitcoin they work with a company called bitpay they accept dollars what happens there are no merchants that price their merchandise in Bitcoin it's impossible it's a gimmick you try to forget an 8.8 there to know they don't invited that the Fiat dollars it's no it's being problem to Reno finance knowingly let me go China I didn't interrupt you using it there is missing the whole story here their units know their use people are using it to circumvent currency laws to transfer money out of China they are not really losing it in commerce no merchants are priced you find me a merchant that is pricing their merchandise in a Bitcoin I like this is one Bitcoin this is a half a Bitcoin there are i donated dollars or you're losing it in the supply chain it's very useful yeah it's it's the price that the volatility is too great on a daily basis to really play meanwhile horse the desert was less volatile than gold and house before it's not it is not less volatile but look meanwhile here gold gold gold gold had a long history of intrinsic value before it was money people desired it for its properties and it was very scarce so it had a lot of value because it's unique properties were hard to come by nobody knew what bitcoin was five or ten years ago it didn't exist it has no value other than the fact that maybe you could use it to exchange for somebody else on if they don't want it has no value and how's the exact no I think golfing value is gold us exactly no it doesn't its usefulness it's you know Hilla tea that's what everything is back Noah no it's not wrong so you hide and walk and have some special qualities what is the county rock look no look look you're you're a member of a cult that's why you have to keep really happy to stop you there's nothing that you can do with your Bitcoin does that mean it's not going to go out fishing the bounty or three thousand here look and that is going to go and zeros my big clip so i can get there is no one in epic what are you talking about unfortunately we are there is no limit there is no limit could there is no limit to the number of digital currencies that can be created there are hundreds of others just because bitcoin is the most popular now look why doesn't everybody use myspace you know because somebody came up with facebook I mean you have no idea and meanwhile cities are popping up money actually I his gold it has a money thing about the internet and all right guys we gotta understand we're gonna try again we're going to find the moment of truth out right now you all heard the arguments so let's go around the horn here and see who the traitors think one is a bitcoin org old Tim what do you say i'm going to say gold just because I first of all I think we've got apples and oranges not because I don't agree with what BK saying about what's going on with with crypto currency so I do think it's an inch in time to own gold don't bet the farm on gold don't get overly emotional about goals and don't have too much gold in your portfolio Karen yep I'm going to go with BK and Bitcoin because I believe you get two things you get this sort of the gold kind of argument and then as well you get the whole financial the Pinta element of it and I I don't abide Peters arguments that it's not usable it's a very few gold transactions have to actually happen in physical gold transactions yet it is freely traded you can do that you can do it now with gold money don't you happy to wait you can do it was very well anyway to vote I'm going with because ok then somebody is hacking the voting rbk is right about Bitcoin dot dot dot then I have to be with Tim I you got to go with gold because I think if BK is correct I think actually in the short term gold will outperform and if memory serves not that I was there but I think there were serious at seven debate between then whatever Lincoln and mr.
Douglas so this was the first of seven over a few months I look forward to number two all right so it looks like two to one for Peter Schiff
Comments 0