Peter Schiff Says Gold is a Losing Game

요약 보기

결론: 피터 쉬프가 비트코인을 실패한 자산이라 한 주장은 틀렸고, 모든 자산의 가치는 사람들이 그것에 가치가 있다고 합의하는 데서 나온다는 것이 진행자의 주장이다. 쉬프 주장 요약: 쉬프는 Lewis House 팟캐스트에서 비트코인의 성공은 더 많은 사람이 사는 데 달려 있으며, 부동산(임대료), 주식(배당), 채권(이자), 원자재(석유·금의 산업적 용도)와 달리 비트코인은 현금흐름이나 실물 용도가 없다고 비판했다. 진행자 반론: 진행자는 2년간 비트코인 책을 쓰며 얻은 결론으로, 자산의 가치는 사람들이 가치 있다고 합의하는 데서 나오며 이는 금과 부동산도 마찬가지라고 주장한다. 따라서 쉬프 논리대로면 금도 실패한 게임이 된다고 역공한다. 진행자 입장: 비트코인에는 자체 고유의 가치 제안(‘비트코인의 다섯 가지 초능력’이라는 다른 영상에서 설명)이 있다고 주장하며, 사람들이 가치 논쟁에 걸려 기술 자체를 이해하지 못한다고 지적한다. 구독·좋아요 및 댓글 참여(동의 여부 질문)를 요청하며 마무리한다. 가격 방향에 대한 구체적 예측이나 목표가, 기간 언급은 없다.

다듬은 글

※ 자동 자막 원문(다듬기 전)

01. did you hear Peter Schiff said gold is a losing game well you know most people who love gold tend to also love Bitcoin so it's really mind-boggling to me that a gold guy like Peter Schiff continues to fail to understand Bitcoin welcome to the crypto Bullseye show my name is Kirk David Phillips and I make common sense of the crypto space so first let's dive into Peter Schiff who is he and what's his background so Peter Schiff is a financial professional who's been around for several decades and he is also on many media Outlets he is the owner of Europe Pacific Asset Management chairman of shift gold many other entities and most of those offer some type of a gold based investment product okay so this is this guy is known as a gold guy he is like the gold bug okay so he was on Lewis house podcast and the title of the podcast or at least the topic was why cryptocurrency is a losing game so I just want to break down a quote here by Peter Schiff okay so he says that the truth is the real success of Bitcoin rests on more people buying it if you own it you need to get many of your friends or colleagues to buy it because that's the only way prices go up Bitcoin is not an asset like real estate where you can collect rent stocks where you can collect a dividend or bonds where you get paid interest it's not like a commodity where you actually can use it for something like oil to generate power it's not like gold where you can make jewelry out of it or conduct electricity or use it in all sorts of industrial applications so that's his breakdown so where he says the truth is the real success of Bitcoin rest on more people buying it that is the key takeaway statement right there because I can tell you that the truth is the real success of fill in the blank any asset rests on more people buying it so after spending two years writing that book right there the ultimate Bitcoin business guide and studying economics and money and all those types of things which most people I think take for granted I really had to dive into it and it felt like thinking about it really for the first time so I distilled down after writing that entire book that the reason things have value is because people agree that they have value and that is the end of it so that means that the real success of gold rests on more people buying it the real success of real estate rests on more people buying it so the real the the real success of any asset is based on more people buying it mean that it doesn't have any intrinsic value outright it's just because human beings say that it has value and that's it so therefore that's why I'm saying that if Peter Schiff says that Bitcoin is a losing game he's also saying that gold is a losing game okay and so by the way if you want to know how Bitcoin has value I can tell you that also go down below in the show notes and you can watch my other video on the five superpowers of Bitcoin so we won't dive into that here go watch that video and I'll explain it to you how Bitcoin does have its own unique value proposition like many of the other assets that Peter Schiff mentioned so and I can also tell you that my observation is over the years that many people will like if you get into a Bitcoin or crypto conversation many people will kind of go into you know why you'll understand why it has value and they'll get hung up on that and they get so hung up on that aspect alone that it blocks them from being able to understand anything else about the technology so that's the key thing that is where people get blocked and that's why I wanted to bring this up today because this is the essence of Peter schiff's assertion and how I just debunked it so what I want to know is if you agree with me you can either type yes if you agree with my assertion that the truth is the real success of any asset rest on more people buying it and agreeing that it has value or if you don't agree with that right now or you can give me the thumbs up or the thumbs down okay I would really like to know what uh what people are thinking about this topic here so in addition please go like subscribe below because we can continue to keep bringing you great content here and a great analysis from a trusted source and keep bringing you other great content as well from crypto Bullseye that's all for now foreign