저자: JimCramer—영상자체는Cramer발언을분석·비판하는내용이므로출연자주장추출은제한적임 · 외국인
요약 보기
결론: 영상은 짐 크레이머의 과거 시장 발언(2020년 3월 '매수' 권고 등)이 일관성 없고, 그의 액션 얼럿 플러스 포트폴리오가 장기적으로 S&P500에 뒤처졌다고 주장한다. 크레이머 발언의 일관성 문제: 한 달 전 '지금이 매수 시점'이라고 했다가 이후 '바닥 확인 필요', '대공황 임박' 등으로 말을 바꿨다고 지적한다. 영상은 이를 신뢰할 수 없는 조언의 근거로 든다. 성과 근거: 2001년 이후 액션 얼럿 플러스 포트폴리오가 S&P500 대비 누적 수익률에서 뒤처졌다고 Wharton 연구를 인용한다. 2014년 수익률 1.3% 대 S&P500 11.4%, 최근 15년간 크레이머 추천 64.5% 대 S&P500 70% 이상을 예시로 든다. 과거 예측 실패: 2008년 바닥 call 실패, 2008년 천연가스 강세 예측 실패 사례를 들며 예측 정확도에 의문을 제기한다. 종목·자산 언급: 영상에서 대상 목록 자산에 대한 구체적 가격 방향 예측은 명시되지 않는다. 시장 전반(S&P500 등) 하락 가능성만 간접 언급된다. 리스크·조건: 실업 지표 악화(70만 명 일자리 감소, 실업수당 청구 약 1,000만 건)를 근거로 대공황 가능성을 크레이머가 언급했다고 소개하며, 영상 제작자는 이를 인용하되 신뢰하지 말라고 권고한다. 출연자 전망: 크레이머는 '지금은 매도', '대공황 우려'를 말했으나 영상 제작자는 이를 과거 발언과 모순된다고 평가한다.
다듬은 글
a mr. Kramer is a time to buy yes you're absolutely correct son it is time to buy Shawn it is time to buy I think we're in a virtual depression so time to sell sell sell Jim Cramer I start that if you're into a stock market you've probably seen the face heard the voice of the myth the legend himself mr.
Jim Cramer so today we're gonna be taking a deep dive look into this misinformation and the lack of consistency when its thoughts and his ideas and talking about how you could actually outperform the market by doing the opposite of what he says now quick disclaimer I watched mr. Kramer when I was getting to herpes and give that bad information you know some of his ideas are pretty sick they make sense and resonate with people but he's more of a person that just likes to make people feel good about their positions and then instantly the switch to the first video we're taking a look at is his most trusted favorite indicator it's telling West a great time to buy and so this video was put out about a month ago so if it's his most trusted indicator man he must be right this must be the perfect opportunity to buy and use me the SNP doubts put out by market edges as the source I like to credit something it's so important in my thinking this darn thing is so reliable that even in the midst of a bearish biological bond crisis it allowed stocks to win the rap what does not Slater do it measures buying or selling pressure and in particular tells us when the selling may have gotten out of control when you are caught up in a Vince you may not actually know the things have gotten out of control you're looking for totems for benchmarks for tokens anything that makes you feel like wait a second and that's why I pay for market coms Iceland untreated indicator is is something used by a lot of investors and so he must be right right obviously he's not gonna change his mind once he said that yes this is a good time to buy obviously he's gonna continue to stick with that right definitely no more changing up his view towards stock market foreshadowing and I'll give it to him he continues to stick to his word for another week when he releases another YouTube video saying stops keep adding to your position into weakness and love man he's definitely sticking to his gut saying man this is the time to buy and these are stocks you should be.i not to mention it was a month ago this man is called a bottom a month ago he said stuff sore bottom a and if he seems it must be but but it must be bottom aid office Mr Cameron can be wrong and the fact that he believes to stop smirking bottom the month ago you know is definitely not gonna change his opinion I doubt he's gonna take back from his words lie to the people listening to him right he's not going to screw them over well next so he says Wall Street must reattach looks after president Don to ruin awakening Oh Mr prettiman I thought you called the bottom and see you guys this is what happens when you listen to people online you listen to me but don't listen to mr.
Kramer going back and introverted as usual but wait until you see the rest it just gets even crazier and that same really of that day you also mentions that investors must be patient until Wall Street retest the marsh lows but mr. Cramer weren't you calling a bottom weren't you saying that it's time to buy us time piling the stocks a month ago when the market was still falling then two days ago mr.
Luthor with you and since Wall Street is desperate for good news who's coming from someone who is providing people with false good news a month ago when the market was crashing and you see this is why people should make decisions for themselves and not rely on information provided by others it's good to take into account what a bunch of people are saying we're relying on one sole person like mr.
Kramer himself that's not right mr. Kramer if the watching this video which you probably are because I'm bad or youtuber and he's probably you're probably subscribed and like in this video right now that the rest of you guys please don't provide false information one thing I want to bring up is that these CNBC televisions have done such a good job and persuading and using propaganda to essentially convince the American people and the world people worldwide to max out their 401ks and put money into the market that we've seen millions of people lose trillions of dollars when Rock falling right off a financial cliff watch out for these false gurus and buy my course for a million dollars link down below and now the absolute finale we could be on a verge of a depression bro what he literally just said the market was going up and now he says we're going to a depression what yes sir the man the myth and legend himself has finally spoken that we could be on a verge of depression hey and I'm not gonna argue with this I think he may be right with this one but the fact that he was telling people to buy and pile on the stocks bro like hold up a minute that isn't zebra and the whole recent mr.
pyramid does all this stuff is to promote not a course like we see these mirrors on YouTube doing but to promote his actions of the group but I believe a $15 a month fee and now if this doesn't seem like the scam I don't know what is he's making fat stocks from CNBC and it's Action Alerts group so for a man promoting of course just like people are doing YouTube and promoting of a group I mean what else could be worst and I will be taking a look into his Action Alerts group and truly see does it outperform the market I'll be taking a look at a research report talking about how you could actually outperform the market by doing the complete opposite or what mr.
Cranmer tells you it's a real study real science real fast video so in a paper published by the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania so this is a big business would you go to Warren bro that's pretty sick and Warren if you're watching this video man he please offer me full ride scholarship please and thank you so basically they published a paper work saying well they talked about that Kramer's Action Alerts PLUS portfolio has in fact underperformed the S&P index in terms of total cumulative returns in this 2001 section I mean what else proof do you need and while fun outperform the fat the index in the 2008 financial crisis it it hasn't done so well since then in fact it just was 1.3 percent in 2014 whereas the S&P rose eleven point four so you'd have a better chance of making more money how you just put your money in the S&P index rather and listen to Cramer and it's Action Alerts PLUS Group in fact over the past 15 years if you would have put money into a Kramer's action in the loop you would have got a solid return of sixty four point five percent which honestly isn't that 64.5% it's a pretty good return but compared to the S&P you were a lot of massive whooping 70% returned the SP went up over seventy percent during those 15 year period so you have him right there who should you be investing in should you be trusting Cramer by the SP it's simple just the S&P would have beat him and one more thing we want to take a look at is his past performance this is a strange stuff but in the past more than just his actually lyrics group failing to beat the S&P in 2008 he tried calling the bottom of the market British times the only to fail and causing message so there's a ton of money not to mention he said 2008 would be the year of natural gas and at the charm natural gas in 2008 ouch I saw gets it ouch AHA another good day of scam and all these people another day of mad money another time failing the market at the end of the day Jim Cramer is an entertainer and he does his job pretty well of entertaining people but the education value he provides isn't at the top of the list if you just look at the multiple studies conducted this man's has underperformed the market for years and years and advise people on picking the wrong stocks and exiting and entering the wrong points like imagine people who might have entered when he called the bottom a month ago and now the path they must be feeling what he says we're on the verge of depression okay I'm coming by i'ma buy oh yeah ah tit oh my god the market is fine what I do what I do what I do it's not called the bottom unless you eat this way well mr.
Kramer gotta say today we could be on the verge of a depression not a recession a depression if things don't go right we just got the worst monthly employment report since 2009 700,000 jobs loss and that doesn't even cover the last two weeks were we had nearly 10 million jobless claims the bad numbers are just beginning which is why the averages got hit today we're on a words of a depression what just put my life savings into the market
Comments 0