저자: ErikVoorheesvsPeterSchiff-비트코인찬반토론 · 외국인
요약 보기
2018년 7월 뉴욕 소호포럼 비트코인 찬반 토론 영상으로, 암호화폐가 법정화폐를 대체할 수 있는지가 주제이며 토론 결과 찬성측 Erik Voorhees가 청중투표에서 승리했다고 보도함. 토론 결과: 찬성(Voorhees) 지지율 40%→55%(+15%p), 반대(Schiff) 40%→31%로 하락. 찬성측(Voorhees) 주장: 비트코인은 희소성·불변성·분할성·내구성이 우수한 화폐이며, 법정화폐는 나쁜 화폐이고, 금은 위조·운송 등에서 한계가 있어 비트코인이 대부분의 논쟁에서 승리한다고 주장. 반대측(Schiff) 주장: 암호화폐는 기술이 아니라 투기 목적으로 보유되며, 약 60% 하락 등 변동성이 커 가치저장 수단이 아니고, 금이 수세기 동안 검증된 화폐라고 주장. 비트코인 가격 관련: 발언 중 연초 이후 약 60% 하락했다는 과거 언급이 있으나 이는 과거 설명이며, 향후 1~3개월 가격 방향에 대한 명시적 예측은 없음. 토론 중 Voorhees가 Schiff에게 첫 비트코인 거래를 시연한 장면이 언급됨. 출연자 전망: 두 발언자 모두 명확한 단기 가격 예측을 제시하지 않음.
다듬은 글
Bitcoin or a similar form of cryptocurrency will eventually replace government's fiat money as the preferred medium of exchange was the resolution forum rollicking debate between shapeshift CEO Eric Voorhees affirmative and hero Pacific Capital and CEO Peter Schiff prominent cryptocurrency skeptics negative in a victory for the crypto community at large mr.
Voorhees was judged the winner by audience vote moving 15% of the assembled crowd to support the resolution mr. Schiff managed to actually lose his base support by the end of the night having been thoroughly beaten the winner earned bragging rights and the traditional tootsie roll also read 27% of England's mail Millennials say Bitcoin better investment than property Erik Voorhees vanquishes Peter Schiff had sold out New York Bitcoin debate New York City's gritty famed Bowery district is home to the recently reconfigured Soho forum functioning as a debate society it is hosted by the affable and nebbish Jean Epstein economics editor of Barron's the Sohail forum featured Bitcoin pioneer Erik Voorhees and well-known conservative libertarian issue economic media personality Peter Schiff fizzled out standing-room-only audience at the subculture theater was treated to a good old Donnybrook of philosophical fisticuffs lasting a full hour and a half including audience questions sans necktie wearing a light-colored suit mr.
Voorhees argued in favor of the resolution defending the idea of crypto finally usurping Fionna Gemini mr. Schiff in a muted royal blue suit with yellow tie met his Challenger to express intense incredulity that magic internet money beans could be anything more than a fetish bubble after brief introductions by mr.
epsteen lincoln-douglas format demands the affirmative position make its case mr Voorhees appealed the crowds natural bias immediately by reminding them of his infamous tangles regarding the state's odious bitlicense affair he cheaply asked the Future Forum debate be held on which is now more socialist China or New York he also paid homage to his Knights sparring partner mr.
Schiff in that the bearded gold bugs podcast as far back as 2008 was an influential factor in mr. for he's embracing of free markets mr. Vorhees argued four main points why bitcoin is good money why Fiat is bad money why gold is insufficient and lastly why bitcoin will win most of the arguments it might be fair to say veterans in the space have heard bitcoins being provable scarce it's immutability it's near infinite divisibility it's durability with regard to the vast network of computing power worldwide at its disposal anticipating mr.
shifts reliably arguing in favor of gold mr. Vorhees was keen to contrast bitcoins many advantages over the ancient metal including the basement in counterfeit issues Bitcoin can't be filled with tungsten for example Peter ships valiant effort falls very flat Peter Shiff came to prominence during the 2008 Great Recession having predicted his word the real estate bubble and subsequent crash he claims same of the.com shake out his viral videos of braving Occupy Wall Street virgins toe to toe made for compelling viewing tonight however he was the mister Schiff who just cannot see his way to accepting crypto as anything near legitimate the resolution somewhat pigeonhole him is essentially arguing in favor of Fiat but of course everyone who knows knows mr.
Schiff is hardly a fan mr s chief made the off stated claim phew it seems were actually in to crypto currencies for the tech or even their potential as mediums of exchange they are he stated flatly taking a financial position out of pure greed it's being as speculation play was an enormous strike against it and even still if folks wanted to use the decentralized money they were hard-pressed furthermore it's not even a store of value having slit some sixty percent since the end of last year and its present volatility isn't any better he ventured me and at nikkor II of HTTP colon slash slash Lock Chang comm helping at Peter Schiff with his first Bitcoin transaction ever had a great time at the debate tonight Peter was reasonable and curious and it was an honor and privilege to share this stage this evening he acknowledged how the Fiat system that we have now is not going to work but replacing fiat currency with a digital fiat currency is not an improvement either gold was the case mr.
Schiff Kim to make his reliable go-to in every debate the mere fact of gold having been around for centuries was proof enough Bitcoin is no match he asked rhetorically what are the odds that bitcoins the best cryptocurrency that's ever going to be invented gold he maintained has never been improved upon in the end the men settled on some agreement governments can outlaw Bitcoin something gold has been able to function reasonably well under Bitcoin might very well not be the final crypto standing most people find comfort in government-issued money mr.
Vorhees countered that bitcoins utility in areas of remittances cross-border nature being deflationary and censorship resistant carried the day audience polling prior to the debate head mister for he's and mr. shifts positions at 40% approval each the debate formally terminated when it was announced mister for he's gained a whopping 15 percent of the voting audience to his side 55 percent while mr.
shifts support plunged to just 31 percent after the victorious mr. Vorhees and friend and equally important ecosystem pioneer Nick Kerry dined with Peter Schiff and were able to fashion him with a first Bitcoin transaction our debates an important way to educate about crypto let us know in the comments images via the pixabay Twitter verify and track Bitcoin cash transactions on our BCH block Explorer the best of its kind anywhere in the world also keep up with your holdings VCH and other coins on our market charts it's the Toshi pulse another original and free service from Bitcoin calm
Comments 0