저자: Apefather · 외국인
요약 보기
결론: 로빈후드 대신 피델리티 등 주문흐름 대가(PFOF)를 받지 않는 증권사로 옮겨야 한다는 주장이다. [켄 그리핀 청문 영상 해석] - 영상 속 켄 그리핀(시타델 증권)이 같은 수량·종목의 주문이라도 로빈후드 경로 주문과 피델리티 경로 주문 중 누가 더 좋은 체결가를 받는지 명확히 답하지 못했다고 주장한다. - 체결 품질은 주문 경로(채널)에 따라 달라진다는 그리핀의 답변을 회피로 해석한다. [PFOF 및 체결 문제 주장] - 로빈후드는 주문흐름 대가를 받고 시타델 등에 주문을 넘기며, 이 때문에 체결가 개선 폭이 낮을 수 있다고 주장한다. - 주문이 다크풀로 들어가 지연되거나 장기간(10~20일) 지연된다는 주장을 제기하나 근거는 제시되지 않았다. [피델리티 이동 권고 3가지 이유] - 첫째, 시타델의 주문흐름 대가 지급을 끊기 위함이다. - 둘째, 피델리티 Active Trader Pro로 매수하면 다크풀·마켓메이커·지연 없이 거래소(뉴욕증권거래소 등)로 직접 들어가 실제 매수 압력이 생기고, 이것이 AMC 주가를 올려 공매도자에게 마진콜을 유발한다는 주장이다. - 셋째, 모든 개미가 피델리티로 옮기면 실제 주식 보유량(약 5억1300만주 언급)을 넘어서는 시점에 공매도 측이 실물을 구하지 못해 합성 주식(synthetic shares) 규모가 드러난다는 주장이다. [종목 및 방향 관련] - 언급 자산: AMC. 피델리티로 이동 시 AMC 주가 상승(매수 압력) 및 마진콜 발생을 주장하나 구체적 목표가·기간은 없다. [리스크 및 조건] - 영상의 핵심 주장(지연 주문, 합성 주식, 마진콜 유도)은 검증되지 않은 음모론적 서술이며 근거 수치가 제시되지 않았다. - 출연자 본인의 AMC 보유 여부 및 이해관계는 확인되지 않는다. [출연자 전망] - AMC 가격이 주문 채널 변경으로 인해 상승할 것이라는 낙관적 전망을 유지한다.
다듬은 글
this video it''m an entertainer the one and only eight father in the house baby wow so just in the rare case that you're still on robin hood or any of the uh paid for order you know platforms such as weeble td ameritrade e-trade you know and charles schwab take a good look at this and tell me if after you see this that you don't want to run to fidelity are you ready okay let's watch this film just tell me when you're ready you're ready and you're paying for the robin hood order flow is that customer getting is the revenue customer getting as good of price as the fidelity customer the execution quality that we can provide as measured in terms of price improvement is heavily related or correlated to the size of the order that we receive so if i were to speculate don't tell me that it's that there are other factors involved and take us down another road i'm asking you a clear question assuming same sides of work one comes in from robin hood one comes in from fidelity so as as i was trying to explain because the rocket hit order comes from a community a community of traders who tend to trade in smaller size that isn't my question sir you're updating my question by making up other questions let me repeat two identical orders come in same stock same quantity what's for robinhood what's your fidelity what happens the quality of the execution varies by the channel of the order this is a commonly understood phenomena in economics that channels matter so for example when you go get a mortgage a mortgage from jp morgan to their clientele has a different rate of interest okay i'll be reclaiming my time sir who gets the better deal one that comes from a broker who is uh paying uh being paid for order flow and one not can you testify that on balance there's no difference assuming the same size of the order so as i said earlier size of the order is only one factor you are doing a great job of wasting my time you should like if you're going to filibuster you should run you notice at the end how we call them a schmuck i don't know if you noticed that he called him a schmuck listen it's a simple question right you have the same exact order the same size order one's coming from robinhood one's coming from fidelity who gets the better deal what happens ken griffin can't answer the question the reason why i can't answer the question because it's very simple because he controls what's going on with robin hood you not only are you not getting the best execution price okay he's failing to mention how he controls that money you know goes into the dark rules he get delayed forever you know i've heard that this guy has delayed orders upwards of 10 20 days okay so then he's trying to act like paid for order flow this is a new thing now oh it's an expense i don't care about it like gary gunzler bannon all right listen the bottom line is this okay here's the bottom line every single ape needs to go to fidelity for basically for three reasons okay let's talk about it the first reason is we want to end citadel's payment for order flaw that's the first reason the second reason is that when you buy on fidelity when you're using the active trader pro app it's like it's there is no dark pools there is no market makers there is no delay orders it's going directly into the lit market directly into the new york stock exchange directly to abc that's called real buying pressure which will raise the price of amc which will force a margin call i don't understand like like you know everyone keeps telling me i want to win a follower right i wanna i want the moaz i know i answer a question right i'll say freaking flying here it's october there's still flies i still love mosquitoes anyway i'll say you want to win right yes you want the moaz right yes okay what platform are you on i'm on robin hood what's the matter with you what platform are you on i'm on weeble oh my god switch to fidelity it's a chariot of fire that will take us to pluto okay and then the third reason here's the third reason this is the big reason everyone keeps saying a faller how are we going to find out about the synthetic shares okay how are we going to find out you want to know how we're going to find out if every single ape went to fidelity can i tell you what's gonna happen eventually we're going to surpass the 513 million shares and then fidelity is going to have to locate shares because if every ape went to fidelity we're gonna we own the float right we own the flow correct okay so if we switch to fidelity we're going to have all the real shares and then they're going to be like wait a minute uh you know someone's switching to fidelity right to be like i got the example like the eight follower i got 3 500 shares right they're gonna be like wait a minute we we've already processed five 500 or 140 million shares uh so where are these shares so now they're gonna have to go knock on citadel's door and be you know can you explain what's going on here so you know what that's how you're gonna find the synthetics it's isn't it so simple it's just so simple and yet and yet like no one is so many few people are doing this i gotta tell you i talked to apes they're on weeble still you know they're on they're on robin hood still okay i just don't get it but anyway i was hoping that video would if if not if my words are not enough you heard it directly from the piece of garbage himself ken griffin who couldn't even answer a simple question because payment for order flow is in his best interest to delay orders to not give you the best execution price and to keep everything tied up in the dark pools which equals a fake amc price thank you
Comments 0